Nepal-Tibet Like Flood Risk to El Chaltén in Argentina

|

,

In a recent Guardian report, María de los Ángeles Orfila travels to El Chaltén, Argentina’s trekking capital, where a disaster like Nepal’s is already mapped out on a scientist’s computer.

She begins her story with geologist Daniela Schmidt of the University of Buenos Aires, who watched the 26 August flood unfold and says she had never seen anything like it. Very few glacial floods, Schmidt realized, had ever reached that scale. But Nepal also changed how she saw her own work.

The flood already on screen

Schmidt reportedly studies what could happen at Laguna Torre, a glacial lake about 5 miles from town.

  • If the slope of Cerro Solo collapsed into the lake, her models show a wave up to 5.8 metres high. The flood could reach El Chaltén in as little as 20 minutes, or up to an hour in the most conservative case.
  • Either way, it would likely destroy the town’s only access bridge.
  • The mechanism mirrors Nepal: a sudden mass of rock or ice plunging into water.
  • Schmidt is blunt. Nobody can predict the day. But, she says, it is going to happen.

Why the risk is growing

Orfila explains that the Torre glacier is shrinking, and the mountains around it are shifting.

  • Between 1952 and 2023, the glacier’s ice thinned by 60 to 70 metres.
  • As the ice retreats, the slopes lose support. Landslides have grown, and the ground now moves twice as fast as it did two decades ago.
  • A key new finding changed minds. Melting has created a deeper basin in the lake, now over 220 metres deep. Earlier estimates put it at about 80.
  • Park superintendent Horacio Pelozo admits the first studies were not alarming. The 2025 collapse that buried the Swiss village of Blatten helped change that.

A town that could be cut off

The flood would reach far beyond the riverbank, Orfila reports.

  • Gas and power plants, schools and homes sit close to the river. Some relocation is already being discussed.
  • Mountain guide Paula Chaparro describes a chain reaction: lose the bridge, lose gas supplies, then generators, then electricity.
  • In peak summer, more than 27,000 locals and tourists could be stranded.
  • Residents say there are no evacuation signs in town, and hotels don’t warn guests.

Preparing, slowly

Authorities are now working on Argentina’s first early-warning system for glacial floods.

  • The national park has moved a campsite, rerouted trails, added warning signs and set out an evacuation plan.
  • Six monitoring stations with cameras, sensors and buoys are planned, to send alerts by siren, text and email.
  • But funding cuts have stalled it. The system costs around $220,000, more than the park can currently afford.

Tourism versus truth

Orfila describes a quieter tension in a town that lives on visitors.

  • Some residents worry that talking about the risk will scare tourists away.
  • Hotel owner Eduardo Marino was asked to drop the subject until the season ended. He refused.
  • Chaparro’s view is that closing down is not the answer. Offering other trails and activities is. It’s not about fear, she says. It’s about staying alert.
  • Guide Ariel Puntin finds the hardest part is the gap between “it could happen today” and “it might never happen.”

Orfila sums up the article on a hopeful note. Schmidt sees Nepal as both a warning and a chance to prepare. And bookseller Sofía Bonangelino says something has shifted as the science has been explained. People now accept the danger is real. The town depends on tourism, she says, and it has no intention of neglecting it, or its safety.

Acknowledgement: This summary was generated using AI writing tools as part of my AI exploration process. For more information, check out the original article listed below.

Related Resource Link