The “Wild West” of AI in Schools


In a recent NPR News report, reporter Lee V. Gaines examines how schools across the country are experimenting with AI despite limited research on its benefits and risks.

Gaines highlights the experience of students at an alternative school in Dayton, Ohio, who spent several weeks interacting with a social-emotional learning chatbot called Jordan. The chatbot was designed to encourage students to open up about their emotions and experiences. One student, identified as K, told NPR that responding to Jordan sometimes helped him work through his own problems.

The Dayton school district reportedly paid SchoolAI $72,600 last school year for several AI tools, including Jordan. Gaines adds that the district has since renewed the contract for $78,650 and plans to continue testing AI tools at the school.

Gaines highlights several key issues schools are facing as they explore AI:

  • Limited research: Gaines notes that research on how schools can use AI effectively while avoiding potential harm remains limited. A Stanford University review of more than 800 academic papers found that carefully designed AI tools may show more promise than general-purpose chatbots.
  • Difficulty measuring results: Gaines reports that schools are still struggling to measure whether AI programs actually help students. A consultant who evaluated Dayton’s pilot said his tests could only capture how students and staff felt about it. Wichita’s AI specialist said her district has not yet decided what success should even look like.
  • Different approaches: Gaines describes how districts are taking different approaches. Wichita Public Schools has introduced AI gradually and with limited student access, while New York City and Los Angeles have placed restrictions on student-facing AI tools.
  • Concerns about vulnerable students: Education researcher Rebecca Winthrop of the Brookings Institution cautions against broadly experimenting with AI, particularly with marginalized students. She supports more targeted uses of AI that address specific problems educators face.
  • Community concerns: Gaines also highlights a planned AI humanoid robot in a New York school district that was put on hold after teachers, parents and state education officials raised concerns, including about student data privacy.
  • The case for engaging: Robin Lake of the Center on Reinventing Public Education, who calls the current landscape the “Wild West,” agrees AI poses real risks. But she warns that closing off experimentation entirely could leave students unprepared for a world changing faster than schools can keep up. She says the questions are too big for districts alone and need state and federal leadership.

Overall, Gaines’ report shows that schools are moving forward with AI while still trying to determine what works, how to measure its impact and how to protect students. Some educators urge greater caution, while others warn that holding back carries risks of its own. Both sides agree that clearer guidance is needed.

Acknowledgement: This summary was generated using AI writing tools as part of my AI exploration process. For more information, check out the original article listed below.

Related Resource Link